We hired her for weekdays and a short Sunday shift.

For the first few weeks, Alyssa was perfect. She cooked actual meals instead of Mom’s “toast and cheese” dinners. She made sure Mom took her meds. She got her through her PT exercises without making her feel pathetic. The neighbors loved her. She even dusted the tops of Mom’s picture frames, which I’m pretty sure hadn’t been dusted since Clinton was president.

Every Sunday after lunch, she took Mom for a slow walk around the block. Mom loved it—fresh air, a change of scenery, a chance to gossip about whose garden looked best.

Then something… shifted.

At first, it was tiny. Mom started coming back from those Sunday walks looking a little off. Not upset, exactly, just tense. Her smile felt forced, like she was holding something back.

“How was the walk?” I’d ask.

“It was nice, honey,” she’d say.

Same words, same tone. Every single week.

The first time, I believed her. By the fourth or fifth, my stomach started doing little backflips. My mother is many things, but she’s not a broken record.

Last Sunday, they came back, and I knew something was really wrong.

I was in the hallway when the front door opened. Alyssa’s hand hovered near Mom’s elbow, and Mom’s eyes were red and puffy. Not just tired. She looked shaken.

“That walk tired me out,” Mom murmured and headed straight for her room.

Her hand was trembling on her walker.

Alyssa gave me a quick smile. “She did well,” she said. “We took it slow.”

“Mm,” I answered, because I didn’t trust my voice.

A few weeks earlier, we’d installed one of those video doorbells for Mom. Motion-activated, picks up audio too. It was mostly for my peace of mind while I was at school—who’s coming and going, when packages get dropped off, that sort of thing.

That night, once Mark went to bed, I sat at our dining table with a mug of tea and opened the app.

I scrolled to the afternoon clip and hit play.

The video showed the front walkway, the gate, the porch. I heard footsteps on gravel, then the squeak of the gate. Their figures appeared small and warped by the lens.

Then I heard my mother’s voice. Small. Shaky.

“I can’t keep this from my daughter,” she whispered. “She deserves to know what you told me.”

My heart stopped.

There was a pause. Then Alyssa’s voice, low and steady.

“You’re not ready to tell her yet,” she said. “She might… react badly. We should wait a little longer.”

Every hair on my arms stood up.

Mom again, stronger this time. “No. No more waiting. She deserves to know. She’s my daughter.”

I heard a sharp, slow exhale from Alyssa.

“I’m telling you,” she said, “this could change everything.”

“I don’t care,” Mom whispered. “I’m telling her soon.”

The clip ended there.

I replayed it three times, hoping for context that never appeared. No explanation. No details. Just a vague threat hanging over my head: This could change everything.

My teacher brain immediately started writing essays about worst-case scenarios. Was Alyssa manipulating her? Was Mom signing something? Was someone pressuring her about her money?

I barely slept. Mark woke up once and mumbled, “You okay?” and I lied and said, “Yeah, just thinking about lesson plans.”

The following Sunday, I watched the clock until their walk time.

They came back right on schedule. I stood in the living room pretending to dust.

Mom looked worn out. Alyssa’s eyes flicked to my face like she was checking my mood.

“Everything okay?” I asked, light and casual.

Alyssa smiled—too quickly, too bright. “Of course,” she said. “She did great. We sat on the bench for a bit and—”

“Actually,” I cut in, “why don’t you take the rest of the afternoon off? I’ll stay with Mom.”

She froze for a second.

“Oh,” she said. “Are you sure? I was going to finish up her laundry and—”

“I’ve got it,” I said. “You’ve been going above and beyond. Go rest.”

Something flickered in her expression. Worry? Guilt? Fear?

“Okay,” she said slowly. “If you’re sure.”

She grabbed her bag and moved to the door. Just before she stepped out, she turned back and looked toward the hallway where Mom’s bedroom is, like she wanted to say something and couldn’t.

“Bye, Margaret,” she called.

Mom’s door stayed shut.

I closed the door behind Alyssa and locked it, more for the symbolism than the security.

Then I went straight to my mother.

She was in her armchair, hands twisted in the hem of her sweater. She looked up at me and tried to smooth her face into a smile. It didn’t work.

“Mom,” I said quietly, sitting on the coffee table in front of her, “we need to talk.”

Her eyes filled with tears instantly. “Oh, honey,” she said. “I was hoping to… do this better.”

“So there is something,” I said. “I heard you and Alyssa on the doorbell recording last week. I know you’re keeping something from me. And I know you said I deserve to know.”

She pressed her lips together like she was physically holding in words.

“Are you okay?” I asked. “Is she hurting you? Is she asking for money? Is she—”

“No,” Mom said quickly. “No. Alyssa has been nothing but good to me.”

“Then what is it?” I asked. “What could ‘change everything’?”

She looked down at her lap, took a shaky breath, and said, “It’s about your father.”

That sentence hit me like a truck.

“Dad?” I said. “He’s been gone 10 years, Mom. What about him?”

She closed her eyes. “He… wasn’t faithful. Once. About twenty-seven years ago, when you were already grown and out of the house.”

I swear the air in the room shifted.

“What do you mean?” I asked, even though I knew exactly what she meant.

“He had an affair,” she whispered. “With another woman. And she had a baby. A girl.”

My chest tightened. “You’re telling me I have a sister?” I asked. “Just… out there somewhere?”

Mom lifted her head, eyes wet. “Not somewhere,” she said. “Here. Alyssa.”

For a second, I actually laughed. Shock does weird things.

“Alyssa,” I repeated. “Our caregiver, Alyssa?”

She nodded. “She told me during one of our walks. She didn’t want to come to you without proof. She knew you’d be… upset.”

“Proof?” I asked. “What proof?”

Mom hesitated. “This is the part you’ll hate,” she said. “She… took a strand of your hair. From your hairbrush. One day when you came over and left it on the counter.”

I stared at her.

“She took my hair,” I said slowly, “without asking, and used it for a DNA test?”

Mom winced. “She knows it was wrong,” she said quickly. “She told me she regretted it. But she wanted to be sure before she made any claims.”

“And?” I asked. “What did the test say?”

“It said you’re half-sisters,” Mom whispered. “She showed me the results. Twice. She did two tests to be certain.”

My thoughts went everywhere at once: my father, who I’d always thought of as solid and boring in the best way. My adult life suddenly featured a shadow I never knew existed while I was busy raising my own kids.

“She grew up with her mother alone,” Mom continued softly. “Your father gave them nothing. No money. No visits. He told her he’d… take care of things, and then he came back to us and pretended she didn’t exist.”

I felt sick.

“When her mother died,” Mom said, “Alyssa went looking for answers. She found his name. She found me. She knew he was gone. She just wanted to see the life he chose over hers.”

I sat back in the chair across from my mother and rubbed my temples.

“Does she want money?” I asked bluntly. “From you. From his estate.”

Mom straightened a little. “She never asked,” she said. “Not once. But when she told me everything, when she showed me the tests, I looked at her and thought: if your father had done right by her, she would have had the same security you did. So yes, I offered. I’m giving her a portion of what your father left me.”

Anger flared in my chest—hot and irrational. Then a wave of guilt crashed in right after. I’d grown up with two parents and stability. Alyssa had grown up with neither.

“And me?” I asked quietly. “Where does that leave me?”

Mom reached for my hand. “You still have your share,” she said. “I’m not taking anything from you. I’m just… correcting a piece of his wrong.”

I let out a breath I didn’t know I was holding. “And what does she want from me?” I asked. “Personally.”

Mom’s gaze softened. “She wants to know you,” she said. “She said you seem strong. Kind. She said you remind her of the good parts of her mother.”

I barked out a short laugh. “She broke my trust before she even met me,” I said. “That’s a weird way to introduce yourself.”

“She was scared,” Mom said. “She thought if she knocked on your door and said, ‘Hi, I’m your father’s secret daughter,’ you’d slam it in her face. So she went for proof first. Wrong choice. But fear makes us do foolish things.”

Silence stretched between us.

See Continuation On Next Page 👇